Reward-Based Training: Choosing the Right Treats
Share
The success of reward-based training hinges on one critical factor: the treats you use. Not all treats are created equal, and choosing the wrong ones can sabotage your training efforts. Here's everything you need to know about selecting, using, and managing training treats effectively.
Why Treats Matter in Training
Treats are more than just food—they're communication tools that mark desired behaviors and motivate your pet to repeat them. The right treat can accelerate learning, while the wrong one can slow progress or even cause health issues.
Characteristics of Ideal Training Treats
1. Small Size
Training treats should be pea-sized for small dogs, dime-sized for large dogs. You'll give dozens during a session—large treats fill them up too quickly.
2. Soft Texture
Soft treats are consumed quickly without chewing time. Hard treats interrupt training flow and lose the dog's focus.
3. High Value
Must be more appealing than regular food. Think real meat, cheese, or freeze-dried options.
4. Low Calorie
Since you'll use many treats, they should be low-calorie to prevent weight gain.
5. Aromatic
Strong smell increases motivation and helps dogs focus even with distractions.
6. Easy to Handle
Not crumbly, sticky, or messy. Should fit easily in treat pouch.
Types of Training Treats
Commercial Training Treats
Pros: Convenient, consistent size, long shelf life, specifically formulated
Cons: Can be expensive, may contain fillers
Best for: Everyday training, convenience
Freeze-Dried Meat
Pros: Pure protein, highly motivating, lightweight, long-lasting
Cons: Expensive, can be crumbly
Best for: High-distraction training, picky eaters
Fresh Meat
Pros: Highest value, affordable, customizable
Cons: Requires prep, short shelf life, can be messy
Best for: Difficult training challenges, maximum motivation
Options: Cooked chicken, turkey, beef, hot dogs (low-sodium)
Cheese
Pros: High value, easy to cut into small pieces, readily available
Cons: High fat, not suitable for all dogs, can cause digestive upset
Best for: Occasional high-value rewards
Vegetables
Pros: Low calorie, healthy, good for weight management
Cons: Lower value for most dogs
Best for: Maintenance training, dogs on diets
Options: Carrots, green beans, sweet potato, peas
Value Hierarchy: Matching Treats to Training
Low-Value Treats (Kibble, Vegetables)
Use for: Easy behaviors in low-distraction environments, maintenance of known commands, dogs on weight management
Medium-Value Treats (Commercial Training Treats)
Use for: Regular training sessions, moderate distractions, everyday practice
High-Value Treats (Freeze-Dried Meat, Fresh Chicken)
Use for: New behaviors, high-distraction environments, challenging training
Jackpot Treats (Cheese, Hot Dogs, Special Meats)
Use for: Major breakthroughs, extremely difficult behaviors, rare special rewards
Homemade Training Treat Recipes
Simple Chicken Treats
Ingredients: 2 chicken breasts
Instructions: Boil or bake, cut into tiny pieces, store in fridge up to 3 days or freeze
Liver Brownies
Ingredients: 1 lb liver, 2 eggs, 1 cup flour
Instructions: Blend liver and eggs, mix in flour, spread thin on baking sheet, bake at 350°F for 15 minutes, cut into small squares
Sweet Potato Chews
Ingredients: Sweet potatoes
Instructions: Slice thin, bake at 250°F for 3 hours until dried, break into small pieces
Treat Management During Training
Portion Control
- Treats should be max 10% of daily calories
- Reduce meal portions on heavy training days
- Use smallest effective size
- Track treat intake
Storage Solutions
- Treat pouch for easy access during training
- Airtight containers for freshness
- Refrigerate fresh treats
- Freeze in portions for convenience
Variety Strategy
Rotate treat types to prevent boredom and maintain high motivation. Use surprise high-value treats occasionally for jackpot rewards.
Special Considerations
Food Allergies
Use novel proteins (duck, venison) or vegetables. Avoid common allergens (chicken, beef, wheat).
Weight Management
Use kibble from daily ration, vegetables, or reduce meal sizes to compensate for treats.
Sensitive Stomachs
Stick to single-ingredient treats, avoid rich or fatty options, introduce new treats gradually.
Puppies
Use puppy-specific treats or tiny pieces of their regular food. Avoid hard treats that could damage developing teeth.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
1. Treats Too Large
Fills dog up quickly, slows training pace, causes weight gain.
2. Using Only One Type
Dog becomes bored, loses motivation, training plateaus.
3. Treating After Behavior Fades
Timing is everything. Treat within 1-2 seconds of desired behavior.
4. Not Adjusting Meals
Leads to weight gain. Reduce meals on training days.
5. Using Low-Value Treats for Difficult Tasks
Dog isn't motivated enough. Match treat value to difficulty.
Weaning Off Treats
Once behavior is reliable:
- Reward every other time (variable ratio)
- Gradually increase intervals
- Replace with life rewards (play, walks, attention)
- Maintain occasional treat rewards to keep behavior strong
Important: Never eliminate treats completely. Occasional rewards maintain learned behaviors.
Budget-Friendly Options
- Use kibble from daily ration
- Cook chicken in bulk and freeze
- Cut hot dogs into tiny pieces
- Grow vegetables for training treats
- Make homemade treats in batches
Final Thoughts
The right training treats can make the difference between frustrating sessions and breakthrough progress. Invest in quality treats, match value to difficulty, manage portions carefully, and watch your training success soar!
Remember: treats are tools, not just food. Use them strategically, and your dog will be eager to learn anything you teach.
Stock up on training success! Browse our collection of training treats, treat pouches, and reward-based training tools designed to make positive reinforcement training effective and enjoyable.